United States · 59 SKUs scored · avg 44/100
Elmhurst 1925
Elmhurst 1925 is a New York-based plant-milk producer that relaunched in 2017 after converting from conventional dairy. The Milked Oats and Milked Almonds lines use a cold-milling process that skips stabilizers, gums and added oils, keeping ingredient lists unusually short (just grain or nut plus water plus sometimes salt). The unsweetened variants stay in NOVA 2 and deliver meaningful protein. Our pages highlight the trade-off: Elmhurst costs more than Silk or Oatly but cleaner composition often translates into a higher FoodScore.
All Elmhurst 1925 SKUs, ranked
- French Vanilla67
- Hazelnut Lightly Sweetened Hemp Creamer, Hazelnut67
- Skim Fat Free Milk60
- Milk60
- Reduced Fat Milk60
- Vanilla Bean59
- Barista Edition58
- Blueberry Milked Oats, Blueberry58
- Milked Almonds Unsweetened58
- Milked Almonds58
- Milked Brown Rice Barista Edition58
- Milked Oats Original58
- Milked Oats58
- Milked Walnuts58
- Original Milked Oats, Original58
- Pistachio Barista Edition58
- Unsweetened Milked Cashews, Unsweetened58
- Unsweetened Milked Hazelnuts, Unsweetened58
- Unsweetened Milked Walnuts, Unsweetened58
- Vanilla Flavored Milked Oats, Vanilla58
- Vanilla Milked Oats, Vanilla58
- Chocolate Peanut Protein Shake, Chocolate Peanut Protein Shake46
- Barista Edition45
- Cacao Oat Latte, Cacao45
- Chocolate Milked Oats, Chocolate45
- Golden - Milk45
- Milked Hazelnuts45
- All Natural Banana Juice Concentrate, with Natural Mango & Peach Flavors45
- Banana Water, Passion Fruit45
- All Natural Banana Juice Concentrate, Natural Banana, Natural Banana45
- Unsweetened Oat Creamer, Unsweetened45
- Unsweetened Oat Creamer45
- Vanilla Milked Hemp, Vanilla45
- Real Walnut Beverage, Original, Original44
- Premium Pistachio Beverage, Original44
- Premium Pistachio Beverage, Unsweetened44
- Premium Pistachio Beverage, Vanilla44
- Chocolate Milked Peanuts, Chocolate40
- Premium Walnut Beverage, Chocolate40
- Plant Based Rich & Creamy Oat Nog38
- Half & Half37
- Horchata, Caramel36
- Horchata, Traditional36
- Traditional Horchata, Cinnamon & Vanilla36
- Caramel Macchiato25
- Peppermint Mocha25
- Pistachio Creme25
- Pumpkin Spice25
- Heavy Cream24
- Heavy Cream24
- Apple Pie Spice23
- Creamer Plant Based Oat, Chai Spice23
- French Vanilla23
- French Vanilla Oat Creamer23
- Gingerbread Oat Creamer, Gingerbread23
- Hazelnut Oat Creamer, Hazelnut23
- Lavender Vanilla23
- Plant Based Chai Spice Oat Creamer23
- Horchata18
Data source: USDA FoodData Central, Branded Foods dataset. Nutrition Facts values, ingredient lists and UPCs are manufacturer-declared. FoodScore methodology is documented on the methodology page. Manufacturer website: elmhurst1925.com.